Lesson 2

Perimeter vs. Length Lab

Est. Class Sessions: 4

Developing the Lesson

Part 3: Graph the Data

Set Up the Graph. Once the data has been collected, it should be displayed in a point graph. (See the content note for a discussion of different types of graphs.) If your students are new to Math Trailblazers, you will need to give them guidance in drawing their graphs.

Give students copies of the Centimeter Graph Paper Master to make their graph. Before they begin plotting their ordered pairs they will need to set up the graph.

Setting up a grid for graphing requires labeling and numbering the axes. An important question that arises is how to decide which variable to plot on each axis. When making a point graph, it does not really matter which variable is plotted on each axis. However, if several different groups are doing a similar investigation, it becomes difficult to compare data unless the groups set up their graphs in the same way. Therefore, scientists and mathematicians have developed several generally accepted conventions for deciding which variable to plot on each axis.

One such convention is to graph the variable with values that change and that the investigator chooses on the horizontal axis and the variable with values that the investigator finds out during the investigation on the vertical axis. Introduce students to this notion, and let them discuss which variable should be graphed on each axis.

  • Which variable did not change?
  • Which column in the data has numbers that are all the same? (The column for the width of the runways.)
  • The variable that scientists usually put on the horizontal axis is the variable for which you choose the values. For which variable in this investigation did you choose the values? (The length of the runways.)
  • Look at your data table. What letter stands for this variable? (L)
  • Will you graph this variable on the horizontal or vertical axis? (horizontal)
  • The variable that scientists usually put on the vertical axis is the variable that they find the values for in the investigation. Which variable did you find the values for in this investigation? (perimeter)
  • Which column in the data has values that you found? (The column for perimeter.)
  • What letter stands for that variable? (P)
  • Will you graph this variable on the horizontal or vertical axis? (vertical)

Before students graph their data they will need to write the ordered pairs that will be graphed. Since length is the variable on the horizontal axis, it will be the first value in each ordered pair and perimeter will be the second value. Use the data table for the light plane that you prepared as a class to demonstrate how to write ordered pairs before asking students to complete Question 5B in the Collect section of the Student Guide.

If the data is not close to a straight line, there is probably a mistake in labeling the axes, plotting the data, or finding the perimeter. Ask students to look for their mistakes by checking the data for points that are “out of line.”

Students may ask why width is not one of the variables plotted on the graph. Remind them that width is a fixed variable.

So that the graphs for different planes can be compared, students should all scale the axes the same.

How should the horizontal axis be scaled? (Counting by ones on the horizontal axis is appropriate since 0 through 15 will fit.)

To facilitate conversations using the data tables and graphs students have created, ask one student for each plane type to make their graph and data table on a class display that can then be shared with the class during the exploration discussions.

Scaling the vertical axis, however, is not so straightforward.

  • What was the largest perimeter for the largest plane? (34 inches is the largest with the given restrictions.)
  • If we know that the perimeter of the largest runway will be 34 inches, will it be possible to graph all of the data for the heavy-transport plane if we scale the vertical axis by one? (No) How do you know? (If we scale by one we can only graph planes with a perimeter between 1 inch and 20 inches.)
  • What are some other possible ways to scale the graph so that we can include all of the perimeters? (Students may suggest a variety of possible solutions to scaling the graph; for example, by 5s or 10s. Help them to see if they scale by either of these numbers, they will use only a small portion of the graph and that it will be more difficult to see patterns in the data for the smaller planes. Continue to explore this until it is suggested to scale the graph by 2s.)

Plot the Points and Draw a Best-Fit Line. Questions 6–8 in the Graph section of the Perimeter vs. Length Lab pages in the Student Guide can be used to guide students as they graph their data. Question 6 directs students to plot their data points. After students have plotted their data points, they should see that those points form a pattern.

Question 7 asks students to describe the points on their graphs.

  • Do your points form a line? (Yes.)
  • Read your graph from left to right, does your line slope uphill or downhill? (The line slopes uphill.)
  • Why does the line slope uphill? What does that say about the relationship between the length of the runways and the perimeter? (The longer the runway the larger the perimeter.)

If the points lie on a straight line, Question 8 asks students to use a ruler to fit a line through these points. This is called a best-fit line. This line should extend in both directions, intersecting the vertical axis at twice the width of the runway and continuing to the edge of the grid in the other direction. This line is useful for controlling error, identifying patterns, and making predictions. A sample student graph is shown in Figure 5.

Remind students to use a ruler when drawing their best-fit lines. In this case, students' data points should fall on a straight line.

Heavy-transport planes runway data
X
+
A sample student graph showing a best-fit line and dotted lines for using the graph
X
+