Lesson 8

Subtraction Strategies

Est. Class Sessions: 2

Developing the Lesson

Part 3: Number Line Strategies

X

Mike saw 8 penguins on a rock at the zoo. 5 jumped into the water. How many were still on the rocks?

Ask students to draw a simple picture to show what is happening in the problem. Monitor the work and look for evidence that each student understands the whole and the known part and further understands that the action is take away or separate. For example, an understanding of the whole could be shown by a drawing of exactly 8 total objects (penguins). Similarly, an understanding of the known part could be shown by separating out five of those objects or distinguishing two groups in some other way such as drawing a circle around them or crossing them out. See Figure 7.

X
  • How could we solve this problem using a number line?

Use the question to start a discussion of how to use a number line to solve subtraction problems. Have a student demonstrate how to solve the problem on the class number line. See Content Note. Possible strategies are shown in Figure 8.

X

Subtraction Representations on the Number Line. The representations for the different kinds of subtraction problems are a little more subtle and possibly less intuitive than representations of addition. Listen carefully to the students' explanations for their diagrams as they may give insight into their understanding and possibly identify some misconceptions. Do not require that the students come up with the exact same representations as are given here. It is sufficient for now that students have an opportunity to reason about the issue and experiment with developing a representation that makes sense to them.

X

Yesterday, the Zoo Store had 10 stuffed polar bears. They sold some. Today the shop has 6. How many stuffed polar bears did they sell?

Ask a student to draw a picture on the board of what is happening in the picture. He or she might show 10 stuffed polar bears, and then cross out some until 6 are left. The four crossed out shows the answer to the problem.

Refer back to number lines. Since this problem is not a take-away situation, the strategies will likely be somewhat different. Possible representations on the number line are shown in Figure 9. If students think of the problem as a missing addend problem (6 polar bears in the store + bears sold = 10 polar bears total), they may represent the situation as shown in first number line (A). The second number line (B) shows another possible interpretation. Encourage students to develop representations that make sense to them. Then ask them to explain their reasoning to the class as a check on the logic and clarity of their representations and explanations.

X
  • What does each hop represent?
  • Match the numbers in the problem to the numbers on the number line.

Ask students to work in pairs to use number lines to solve the problems on the Number Line Problems pages in the Student Activity Book. These problems include a variety of problem types and can be represented on the number line in different ways. Since the problems can be interpreted as subtraction or addition problems (with a missing addend), students may write either type of sentence. When students complete the page, ask them to model their representations on the class number line and explain their reasoning.

X
SAB_Mini
+
X
SAB_Mini
+
Drawing that shows understanding of 8 − 5 = 3
X
+
Counting back strategies for solving 8 − 5 = 3 on the number line
X
+
Possible representations for solving 6 + = 10 or
10 − 6 = 4 on the number line
X
+